Should you tell people your goal?

One camp says announce it: once people know, you will not dare quit. The other says keep it secret, because talking about a goal feels so good that you stop working for it. Both camps can point to real research. The good news is that they are not really in conflict once you look at what exactly is being made public.

The case for going public: consistency

In his book Influence (1984), the psychologist Robert Cialdini describes commitment and consistency as one of the strongest forces in human behaviour. Once we take a stand, especially in writing, in public and with some effort, we feel pressure to act in line with it. Part of that pressure comes from others, but most of it comes from wanting to see ourselves as people who keep our word.

Cialdini draws on older experiments, including one by Morton Deutsch and Harold Gerard in the 1950s, in which people who wrote down and signed their judgement were far less likely to change it later than people who kept it in their heads. A commitment that exists somewhere outside you is harder to quietly revise.

The case for going public: accountability

The most-cited study on this question comes from Gail Matthews, a psychology professor at Dominican University of California. She recruited people from many professions and countries and split them into groups. Some only thought about their goals. Others wrote them down, wrote action commitments, shared them with a friend, and, in the last group, also sent that friend a weekly progress report.

Over the following weeks, the group that sent weekly updates accomplished significantly more than the group that only thought about their goals, and writing the goals down also helped. The study was modest in size and was presented at a conference rather than published in a major journal, so it is a good signal rather than final proof. But the mechanism it points to is clear: it was not the announcement that helped most, it was the regular report.

Commitment devices: tying your own hands

Economists have their own version of the idea. In 2002, Dan Ariely and Klaus Wertenbroch let students in a course choose their own deadlines for three papers. Many students chose early deadlines, even though a late deadline would have been strictly more flexible, because they knew they would procrastinate. The self-imposed deadlines helped compared with having none, although evenly spaced deadlines set by the teacher worked best of all. People understand their own weaknesses, and they are willing to pay a little freedom to protect themselves from them, even if they do not always set their deadlines perfectly.

Websites like stickK, started by Yale economists Dean Karlan and Ian Ayres, take this further with commitment contracts: you put money on the line and name a referee, and if you fail, the money goes to a charity or even to a cause you dislike. Fresh-start research by Dai, Milkman and Riis found people sign more of these contracts at the start of weeks, months and years. A public date works on the same principle, with your word at stake instead of your money.

The case against: when intentions go public

Now the other side. In 2009, Peter Gollwitzer, Paschal Sheeran, Verena Michalski and Andrea Seifert published a paper titled When intentions go public. They studied identity goals, the kind that describe who you want to become, such as being a lawyer or a psychologist. When participants' intentions to act on those goals were noticed by someone else, they then worked less on them than participants whose intentions stayed private.

The explanation comes from symbolic self-completion theory: if an identity goal is acknowledged socially, you can get some of the satisfaction of having the identity without doing the work. Saying “I'm going to be a writer” and being nodded at can feel a little like being one. Derek Sivers popularised the finding in a short 2010 TED talk called Keep your goals to yourself.

These were a few small experiments about a specific kind of goal, so they do not prove that sharing always backfires. But the warning is real and worth taking seriously.

Resolving it: publish the commitment, not the bragging

Look closely and the two sides are describing different things. What backfires is announcing an identity and collecting the applause in advance. What helps is a specific commitment with a date, followed by regular, honest evidence of progress. One gives you the reward before the work; the other only rewards the work.

So if you are going to go public, go public like this.

  • Make the goal concrete and measurable, not an identity. “Finish the first draft, 80,000 words, by 1 May” instead of “become a novelist”.
  • Attach a date that cannot be quietly moved.
  • Report progress, not intentions. A short weekly note about what moved does more than any announcement.
  • Do not wait for praise to keep going. Treat attention as a side effect.
  • Decide in advance what you will say on the deadline, whether you made it or not.

Why the City of Goals is built this way

That resolution is the design of Build a Goal. Your building shows the commitment and the countdown, not a bio about who you are going to be. The title and Target Date are locked once you plant them, so the promise cannot shrink later. Your private magic link is where you log 📔 Progress Milestones, and those logs are the public part that matters: evidence, in order, of work done.

The 🔥 Root for this goal button gives strangers a way to send free Fuel, and it is deliberately small: one press per goal per visitor per day, no comments to perform for, no follower counts. It says I saw this and I hope you make it. Then the building only changes in a big way when you press 🏆 I Made It!, which means the Golden Roof can only be earned by finishing, never by announcing.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to keep your goals to yourself?

It depends on what you share. Research by Gollwitzer and colleagues found that having identity goals noticed by others, like becoming a lawyer, can reduce effort because it delivers a premature sense of achievement. But sharing a specific goal with a date and sending regular progress updates tends to help. Share the commitment and the evidence, not the self-image.

What did Gail Matthews' goal study find?

In her study at Dominican University of California, participants who wrote down their goals, committed to actions and sent weekly progress reports to a friend accomplished significantly more than those who only thought about their goals. The sample was modest and the work was presented at a conference, so it supports accountability without being the final word.

What is a commitment device?

A commitment device is anything you set up in advance to make quitting harder or more costly: a self-imposed deadline, a bet with a friend, a stickK contract that sends your money to a charity if you fail, or a public date on a goal. Ariely and Wertenbroch showed in 2002 that people use self-imposed deadlines to fight their own procrastination.

Does an accountability partner help you reach goals?

Often, yes, mainly because it creates a regular moment to report what you actually did. The useful part is the recurring check-in, not the one-time announcement. If you do not have a partner, a public log of progress milestones works in a similar way: it gives you a reason to show up and a record that others can see.

Is the famous Yale or Harvard written goals study real?

No. The story about a 1953 Yale class in which the 3% with written goals out-earned everyone else has been searched for repeatedly and never found. It appears to be an invented anecdote. The genuine research on written goals, deadlines and progress reports is smaller and less dramatic, but it exists and points in a useful direction.

🏗️ Build your goal

Updated November 19, 2026